Hello dear
Welcome To Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe
Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe, nestled in Wesley Chapel, FL, captures the essence of authentic New York-style pizza. With a reputation for its thin, crispy crust that resonates with a satisfying crunch, this cozy Italian eatery has won the hearts of locals. Customers rave about the flavorful grandma slices and meatball subs, highlighting the commitment to quality and tradition from its Italian New Yorker owners. The inviting atmosphere further enhances the dining experience, making it a perfect stop for both dine-in and takeout. Whether indulging in a classic pepperoni pizza or exploring other menu offerings, Fratelli’s guarantees a delightful culinary journey.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
House Salad
US$8.95Regular NYC Style Pizza
US$14.95Lasagna
US$13.95
Cheese Ravioli
US$13.95Spaghetti W/ Marinara
US$10.95Pasta W/ Clam Sauce
US$14.95
Baked Ziti
US$12.95Fratelli's Special
US$18.95Sicilian Pizza
US$22.95 About
Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe
Welcome to Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe, a delightful gem located at 5327 Village Mkt, Wesley Chapel, FL. This charming Italian pizzeria captures the essence of New York-style pizza, earning rave reviews from locals and newcomers alike. With its perfect blend of a thin and crispy crust, you can hear the satisfying crunch with every bite, making it feel like a small slice of New York in Florida. Customers like Susan Sanchez have expressed their delight with dishes such as the grandma slice and the white slice, touting them as some of the best pizza in the region—no soggy flops here!
As you step into Fratelli's, you’re greeted by a warm atmosphere reminiscent of a classic Italian eatery. Chance Lau found much more than just pizza; he was excited about the variety on the menu, hinting at succulent offerings beyond their signature pies. Whether you choose to dine in or take out, each plate is prepared with a genuine touch that reflects authentic Italian heritage, first-hand approved by the owner's own family from New York.
The meatball sub here is another highlight that drew praise from J P, describing it as hot from the oven and bursting with flavor. Meanwhile, artful presentations of their other food items leave visitors eager to explore all that Fratelli's has to offer. Indeed, even those often skeptical about finding quality pizza outside New York, like Steven Acevedo, have declared it as the best pizza in Wesley Chapel—an endorsement that reflects the restaurant's commitment to quality.
Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe also provides a welcoming spot to enjoy a meal with friends or family, featuring outdoor seating perfect for enjoying the Florida sunshine. Just remember to grab a bottled soda, as they serve bottled drinks instead of fountain options. Overall, this venue creates a welcoming environment that invites patrons to return for more delectable bites. As Alicia Gonzalez puts it, with the quality and taste paired with reasonable prices, it’s hard to resist coming back for another delightful experience.
So, if you're in the Wesley Chapel area and yearning for an authentic slice of Italy, Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe is undoubtedly worth your visit. Treat yourself to a taste experience that combines tradition with a homely atmosphere—because here, every dish tells a delicious story.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This is one of the closest to NY pizza I've had in FL. The crust is thin and crispy. I love when I can take a bite and hear the crunch of the crust. No soggy flop here. I had a grandma slice and a white slice...both delicious! Very cute little Italian pizzeria. I would definitely recommend...and it's right off of I-75. ”
“ Best Pizza in Tampa! I just happened to find this place today and I won’t be getting Pizza from anywhere else! Their other food looks amazing and I’m supper excited to try it as well! ”
“ Meatball sub was excellent on dine-in, hot out of the oven and flavorful. Had pizza on takeout before and was very good. An Italian couple from New York were eating at a table when I came in, they gave the stamp of approval, but I already knew. These are Italian New Yorkers running this place, so it's authentic. Prices are very reasonable as well. Definitely recommend! ”
“ To be honest, a little skeptical getting pizza here in FL, (from NY/NJ) but Fratelli’s definitely has the best pizza here in Wesley chapel!! I definitely will be back to try various items on the menu!! ”
“ Tried this place for the first time today! So fresh and delicious very nice inside and out front it has two tables each with 4 chairs. Pizza was delicious we had a pepperoni and cheese and I got wings. Took those to go and have not tried them yet. But I know they’ll be good too. Only minor thing is that they don’t do fountain drinks so we ended up with bottled soda. Other than that it was a great experience. They are 10 min away from the house. Will definitely be back in the near future. ”
“ Been living in Wesley Chapel for a year now. We've tried a handful of different pizza spots and have nothing bad to say about any of them.... BUT THIS ONE RIGHT HERE!!!!! Fratelli's has separated themselves from the rest. My families new go to place. The care and attention and quality ingredients. This was an authentic NY pie... and the Grandma Slice.... CHUUUURCH ”
“ The real deal folks!! If you need a fix of good old NYC pizza this is the place. The Grandma's pizza is sublime. Sadly I was too full to try the sausage and peppers. But I will next time.....and there will be a next time! The cheesecake is great as well!! Don't forget to try the white pie. ”
“ I was craving a good baked ziti and this hit the spot! The guys who work here are very polite. We will be back when we are in the area. ”